Repositioning Rooney – Is a midfield spot his future?

by Omar Soliman

Cast your mind back two years to October 2010 and the bombshell that was Wayne Rooney‘s transfer request. Of course, Rooney went on to swiftly sign a new bumper contract yet his reasons for the request were spelt out when he questioned the club’s ability to sign world class players and thus match his ambition. Another league title and a Champions League final place seemed to suggest that the grass is not always greener. Now the club have splurged with the summer acquisitions of Shinji Kagawa and Robin van Persie, you begin to wonder where this all leaves Wayne.

While the team’s performances are still mixed at best, both signings have proved valuable world-class assets to the squad. Though Sir Alex Ferguson is arguably still working out how to best deploy his strike force, the pair have figured majorly even if the season is only a few weeks old. Intriguingly, during Rooney’s injury the results read five wins out of five, masking his absence and perhaps proving he is not as indispensable as he may think.

Could it be that the signings Rooney demanded are now forcing him out of the reckoning? The second half against Spurs certainly seemed to suggest as much as Rooney returned only to influence play on the fringes while Van Persie and Kagawa often found themselves in more dangerous territory. That’s not to dispute his influence as it was his whipped cross that found Nani and momentarily brought United back into the game. However, further up the pitch it was Van Persie’s sliderule pass which found Kagawa for the second, showing early signs of a burgeoning understanding.

Certainly a tactical rethink suggests using Kagawa as a number ten with Van Persie acting as a target man. That would see both in their favourite position and their continued selection will help prove that the outlay was good business. That’s not to oust Rooney as there lies an argument that world-class players can always find a way of playing alongside each other. Indeed, Rooney has proved his status as one of England’s few (if only) world-class players – so where do you put him?

In the games that Rooney has featured in since his return he seems to be undertaking a more withdrawn role to influence play from a position closer to midfield, none more so than his outstanding performance against Newcastle. Perhaps this is one method Ferguson has of shoehorning another forward into his team; simply reposition him. Not that a midfield role should be new to Rooney – during last season he filled in during an injury crisis and did not let the side down with some disciplined performances.

Many have argued that a player of Rooney’s vision would flourish in a playmaker role in advanced midfield and there are similarities to Paul Scholes’ career. Beginning as a striker before dropping back into midfield proved his best position as his attacking instincts were marked by late runs into the box and lurking menacingly at the edge. Rooney himself has said that though he enjoys playing as a striker there is the possibility that a withdrawn role would suit him, there is certainly no harm in finding out.

Against FC Cluj it was Rooney who assisted both of Van Persie’s goals and his ball over the top for the Dutchman’s winner is as  good an indication that he can still provide a telling pass despite being in midfield. It would not be a huge surprise to see him remain there as the season progresses in order to get van Persie, Kagawa and Rooney all starting in the same team.

You may also like

1 comment

ray 10/09/2012 - 09:48

Several important points in this post.

Rooney did not question United’s ability to sign world class players.
What Rooney questioned was United’s desire to invest in players as opposed to bankers and stockbrokers fees and interest charges.
Having seen players like Ronaldo leave and the money not reinvested in the squad it was a legitimate question and the answer it got was to allow Rooney to be sold.
In effect he guessed correctly.
A deal was done with Manchester City and a press release confirming the fact was actually prepared for the press association by Manchester City.
It was only at the eleventh hour that United reopened negotiations and convinced Rooney to stay.
Whether or not it was Sir Alex Ferguson or David Gill that made that decision we will probably never know but i can’t see it being the Glazer family turning down what must have been a huge transfer fee
Rooney did indeed get a mouth watering new contract but with what we now know run of the mill players are getting at Manchester City we can assume what United gave Rooney was significantly less than he could have got across the road.

You now question whether Kagawa and van Persie might make life difficult for Rooney.
I think the answer is an easy no provided that Rooney has his mind on the position.
What we saw at Newcastle from Rooney playing in midfield was his most outstanding performance of the season and in midfield as well.

In the early part of the season after playing for England in the summer and then a short pre season what we saw was an overweight,out of shape player.
We know he has weight problems as we have seen it several times now.
What Rooney can’t do is hide or rely on others.
As a high profile player he is permanently in the limelight.
If United don’t play well up front or score goals then he is blamed.
We haven’t played well up front and we haven’t scored too many goals but that is as much the fault of Welbeck and Chicorito who between them have offered nothing but effort this season.
No skill level and no danger other than to the linesman who pulls a muscle by continually flagging Chicorito offside.

Kagawa has looked good in flashes but so far although we can see he is a good player we cannot say he is a world class player.
His old team did a good job on Manchester City last week without missing him.
You miss world class players.
We miss Ronaldo and van der Saar don’t we?

Van Persie is not a “striking” centre forward.
He is just a world class player with a great football brain and a fantastic skill level to take most chances that come his way.
What an asset he is to United
Rooney is the same.
With them both drifting away from a natural centre forward position and then powering back in at the opportune moment you have a strike force that is hard to work out.
I am not saying either is as good as Messi but look how many he scores coming from a position that both Rooney and van Persie have started to play.
Rooney also relished getting stuck in with his midfield tackling.
I am not sure about his temperament if it got tasty but overall a new lean and fit Rooney excites me in midfield

Reply

Leave a Comment